Social Media Mobs Are Scary As Hell: You Won’t Believe What One Did to This Business Owner

adminCustomer Reviews, Negative Reviews, Public Relations, Review BombingLeave a Comment

Do you think mob behavior affects only those unsophisticated inhabitants of the world’s premodern backwaters? Think again.

This week saw another example of what’s becoming a common Internet phenomenon: an unrelenting, morally- or politically-charged online mob beatdown directed at a business or individual who posted something offensive on social media. (Remember #HasJustineLandedYet?)

Even when the mob is “right,” its behavior is scary. If the offending party is a business or business owner, a lapse in judgment can quickly cost them their reputation, customers, even the business itself and the livelihoods of those it employs.

Even when the mob is “right,” its behavior is scary. If the offending party is a business or business owner, a lapse in judgment can quickly cost them their reputation, customers, even the business itself and the livelihoods of those it employs. And as the sagacious Mike Blumenthal also points out in his post today, a company’s online reviews are increasingly used as a battleground in these wars of words.

Why? Presumably because bad reviews do a ton of real damage. At, we refer to a disgruntled customer who skewers a company on Google+ or Yelp as exercising “the nuclear option.” In case it’s any wonder why, pull up a chair and let me tell you the story of this latest fiasco.

The Saga of One Block West Restaurant

This week, it was chef/owner Ed Matthews of One Block West in Winchester, Virginia, who made a misguided post to Facebook regarding an all-change tip left by a customer:

One Block West offensive post on June 4
Now, Matthews is no stranger to making colorful comments in his online dialogue with patrons of the restaurant. But this one struck a nerve. While some in the food industry might see Matthews as “protecting his own,” he made a brash and public complaint about a customer–described as “ladies,” perhaps as in “little old ladies”–who left an odd tip under unknown circumstances. From a customer’s point of view, Matthews just sounds like an arrogant, ungrateful, mean-spirited jerk. A prick, if you will. A bastard. A prick-bastard.

Are you with me? Yes? So let the punishment begin: Prior to this post, One Block West had a star rating on Facebook in the high 4s, and recent reviews were going swimmingly:

Then, on June 4, a few hours after Matthews’s ill-fated post, something happened. One Block West’s star rating plummeted into the 2s on Facebook. In a span of 2 hours and 15 minutes, 60 new reviews were posted, all of them 1-star ratings accompanied by a large dose of moral upbraiding or vitriol–and occasional mention of the restaurant’s food selection and service. Here’s what that particular kind of terror looks like on a spreadsheet:

One Block West reviews after offensive post

Now, it’s clear that this mob of “reviewers” largely believes that they are exacting some kind of proper justice for the “wrong” of Matthews’s post. They seem perfectly at ease with the idea that their reviews will do real damage–perhaps even destroy–the business, and that Matthews has committed “suicide by Facebook” with his errant post:

  • “How the mighty have fallen! Maybe you should have thought twice about making that pompous post… You have greatly injured your business, over a bag of change! Was it worth it, to try and humiliate patrons? Hope you have to close the doors.”
  • “Were you guys looking for a reason to go under? Well guess you have a reason to close your doors now. Pathetic excuse of a restaurant anyway. End of story.”
  • “I will never visit your establishment, and I think I can guarantee that anyone who has Facebook and have seen that post will never visit you. You’ve sealed your own fate allowing that on a huge social media site. Extremely irresponsible to all the families that depend on the jobs of your employees.”

The barrage continued for a little more than a day before One Block West successfully removed not just the offending post but the reviews widget from its Facebook page. Eventually, a small backlash of supporters arrived to post a handful of 5-star reviews, apparently in an effort to do damage control:

  • “Pathetic that people want to destroy this restaurant’s reputation and the livelihoods of both the owner AND his employees via social media because the owner stood up for one of his servers. You should all be ashamed of yourselves.”

But the damage was done. It remains to be seen how well One Black West recovers. In the immortal words of Warren Buffet,

“It takes 20 years to build a reputation and five minutes to ruin it. If you think about that, you’ll do things differently.”

You can still find the whole One Block West episode played out here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.